Robinson interrogates the persistent alignment of urban theory with western modernity and with the privileged category of “the new”. Her argument is that twentieth-century urban studies repeatedly transformed a narrow set of metropolitan experiences into universal definitions of urbanity, while other cities were positioned as belated, traditional or insufficiently modern. “The urban now” is introduced as an analytical device for breaking this temporal hierarchy. The theoretical contribution is a radical contemporaneity: all cities participate in the present and can therefore contribute to theorising the urban, even when their institutional forms, histories and material conditions diverge. Methodologically, Robinson uses critical genealogy to expose how novelty and exemplarity structure the geography of theory, then reconnects localised urban processes to wider circulations and hybrid histories. The article bridges postcolonial urban studies, cultural theory and Benjaminian accounts of modernity, offering a durable critique of developmental comparison and of the tendency to treat selected cities as privileged previews of everyone else’s future.