Bongers-Römer, S. and Diller, C. (2024) ‘On the role of values in judgements on conflicting planning processes – prospects for agonistic planning? Basic considerations from Germany’, Planning Practice & Research, 39(4), pp. 665–682. https://doi.org/10.1080/02697459.2024.2354120



Planning conflict is not reducible to competing preferences for a shared technical optimum. Through an exploratory examination of German judicial decisions, Bongers-Römer and Diller consider how courts address disputes shaped by interests and substantive values. Their findings emphasise procedural values as essential legal requirements while also documenting consideration of substantive concerns, including environmental protection. The inquiry introduces the court as an institutional actor often omitted from accounts of agonistic planning, while refusing to equate adjudication with participatory deliberation among equals. It is precisely the limited, rule-bound authority of courts that clarifies what formal resolution can and cannot achieve. The study connects planning theory, political pluralism, legal reasoning and governance, and replaces an abstract celebration of disagreement with an analysis of its procedures and consequences. For shared spatial evidence, it demonstrates that incompatible interpretations must be recorded alongside the institutional rules through which some become binding decisions. Preservation of dissent does not remove the obligation to decide; it alters what a defensible decision must disclose.