Jordan, K. and Tsai, S.P. (2026) ‘Keywords, citations and “algorithm magic”: exploring assumptions about ranking in academic literature searches online’, Learning, Media and Technology, 51(1), pp. 60–74. https://doi.org/10.1080/17439884.2024.2392108

 



Academic relevance is not merely discovered; it is operationalised through rankings that users often cannot inspect. Jordan and Tsai combine a survey of academic search practices with co-interpretive interviews and live searches to investigate beliefs about algorithmic ordering, particularly in Google Scholar. Their findings identify uncertainty about ranking and assumptions concerning keyword matching, citations, personalisation and publication metadata. Participants frequently interpreted highly cited, established literature as disproportionately visible, sometimes treating such results as useful orientation but insufficient access to current specialist debate. The analysis concerns users’ beliefs and search practices, not an independent reverse-engineering of the ranking algorithm: that distinction is epistemically decisive. By observing how academics adapt to opacity, the article connects platform studies, information retrieval, educational research and scholarly communication. It exposes the interface as an active site of canon formation. The practical unit of analysis is not simply the retrieved paper but the encounter between a ranking mechanism, an expectation of relevance and the researcher’s decision to follow or contest that order.