Ware, B. (2011) ‘Williams and Wittgenstein: Language, Politics and Structure of Feeling’, Key Words: A Journal of Cultural Materialism, 9, pp. 41–57.



Ware stages an encounter that the two thinkers did not themselves formalise. Starting from Williams’s conspicuous lack of engagement with Wittgenstein, he examines both the criticism of ordinary-language philosophy as politically conservative and the more substantial affinities between their accounts of linguistic practice. Language emerges neither as an autonomous grid of signs nor as a simple instrument of sovereign speakers, but as socially organised activity through which experience becomes intelligible. The argumentative operation is a tension rather than a reconciliation: Wittgenstein’s attention to use can expose the habits through which meaning works, while Williams insists that those habits are situated within class relations and historical struggles. Ware bridges ordinary-language philosophy, cultural materialism and political criticism, shifting the focus from dictionary equivalence to the circumstances in which words are learned and deployed. For a conceptual archive this is a necessary constraint. Metadata can stabilise a label, but it cannot independently establish the social work that label performs. To analyse a term is also to investigate who can use it, in which setting, and with what authority.